At Lorain County Community College, a suite of individual success and completion initiatives is having significant impact and is effecting transformational change at every level of the institution. Within this context, Lorain’s pilot implementation of Campus Compact’s Connect2Complete (C2C) program proved to be a successful journey within a journey. C2C links peer advocacy with peer-assisted service-learning to increase graduation and completion rates for the most vulnerable of community college students. For Lorain, designing, implementing, evaluating, and supporting Connect2Complete required continuous adaptation in response to the changing educational landscape of the College.